How to Handle an eBay Case Without Getting a Defect

The email subject line is enough to ruin your morning: a buyer has opened a request. Maybe the item hasn't arrived. Maybe it arrived and they say it's not what you described. Maybe they just changed their mind and picked whatever reason gets them free return shipping.

How you handle the next three business days decides most of what happens. Handle it well and it's a minor annoyance. Ignore it or fight the wrong battle, and eBay steps in, refunds the buyer with your money, keeps the fees, and puts a defect on your account.

I've sold on eBay for over 25 years and handled plenty of these. Here's how each one works and what to do about it, based on eBay's current rules.

Quick Checklist: Handling a Buyer Request

  1. Respond within 3 business days — that's your window before either side can ask eBay to step in.
  2. Figure out which kind of request it is — not received, not as described, or a change of mind. Each has different rules.
  3. Resolve it yourself if you'd lose anyway — a case eBay decides against you becomes a defect, and you get no fee credits.
  4. Use your protections — valid tracking, signature confirmation at $750+, and photos taken before you shipped.
  5. Appeal with new information — if eBay rules against you and you can prove otherwise, you have 30 days.

Prefer to watch? Here's the whole guide on video, with my real eBay screens:

Request vs. Case: The Difference That Matters

A request is between you and the buyer. A case is when eBay gets involved. Most problems can be settled at the request stage, and that's where you want them settled.

How a buyer request becomes an eBay case A buyer opens a request. You have 3 business days to resolve it. If it's resolved, it's done. If not, either of you can ask eBay to step in. eBay reviews the case and usually responds within 48 hours. If you met your obligations, the case closes in your favor and related negative feedback and defects are removed. If not, eBay refunds the buyer, seeks reimbursement from you with no fee credits, and the case counts as closed without seller resolution, a defect. You can appeal with new information within 30 days. Buyer opens a request You have 3 days business days Resolved No case, no defect eBay steps in Usually responds within 48 hours In your favor Related negatives and defects removed Against you Refund, no fee credits, counts as a defect Either side can appeal a decision with new information within 30 days.

eBay's step-in help page spells out what happens when a case goes against you: eBay refunds the buyer, seeks reimbursement from you, and you don't get fee credits. The case is recorded as closed without seller resolution, which eBay's seller standards policy counts as a transaction defect.

Compare that to refunding the buyer yourself at the request stage: same refund, but you keep your fee credits and avoid the defect. If you're going to lose, lose early.

Item Not Received

A buyer can report that an item hasn't arrived once the estimated delivery date has passed. eBay's item not received page gives you 3 business days to upload tracking and respond.

What protects you

What to do

Not As Described or Damaged

This covers wrong items and items that arrive broken, damaged, faulty or different from the listing. Under the eBay Money Back Guarantee, buyers can return these for a refund even if your listing says no returns.

eBay's return request page lays out your choices:

If you don't respond, eBay says it may refund the buyer and seek reimbursement from you, without the buyer sending anything back. That's the worst outcome: no item and no money.

If it comes back used or damaged

If the buyer returns the item in worse shape than they got it, eBay's seller protections let you deduct up to 50% from the refund to cover the lost value. eBay suggests 5–10% for good condition (like missing original packaging), 15–30% for fair (missing parts, signs of wear) and 35–50% for poor (significant wear or damage). You still have to refund within 2 business days, and the deduction isn't available once eBay steps in.

The catch: it depends on your return policy. eBay's seller protections page says Top Rated sellers qualify only if the listing offered 30-day or longer returns. Other sellers qualify only on listings that offer free returns, as long as they aren't Below Standard. If your listing said no returns, you can't use the deduction, even on a not-as-described return you were required to accept. That's one more reason to think twice before choosing no returns.

Changed Their Mind

A buyer who just doesn't want the item is only covered if your listing accepts returns. If you don't offer returns, eBay's policy leaves it up to you whether to accept.

The catch is that some buyers know this and pick "not as described" instead, because then you pay the return shipping. When the reason doesn't match the item:

I covered who pays what on each kind of return, including a $441 lesson of my own, in the eBay returns guide.

Which Request Is It?

The three kinds of buyer request and what to do Item not received: you have 3 business days, protected by tracking with an acceptance scan and signature confirmation at 750 dollars or more; respond with tracking or refund if it's lost. Not as described or damaged: you must accept even with no returns, you pay return shipping, and you can deduct up to 50 percent if it comes back used or damaged and your listing offers returns. Changed mind: covered only if you offer returns; accept, inspect and report abuse when the reason is false. Not received Protects you Tracking with acceptance scan Signature at $750+ Do this Respond with tracking Lost in transit? Refund or replace, then claim it with the carrier Not as described The rules Must accept, even with no-returns policy You pay return shipping Do this Ask for photos Return, refund, or partial Damaged on return? Deduct up to 50% if you offer returns Changed mind The rules Covered only if you offer returns Reason doesn't fit? Accept if you'd lose Inspect and photograph Report abusive buyers

When eBay Decides Against You

eBay says either side can appeal a decision within 30 calendar days of the case closing, but only with new information. Repeating your side of the story won't do it. Things that can change a decision:

If the case was closed in your favor, or the buyer never shipped the return, eBay says it removes the related negative or neutral feedback, and in the first case the defects too.

Habits That Win Cases Before They Start

Know What Cases Cost You

A case doesn't end when it closes. There's the refund, the return label, any fees you didn't get back, and sometimes a carrier adjustment that shows up weeks later. Those costs are easy to miss in eBay's reports, which split them across different screens.

Autotabit pulls them onto the order itself. The Returns tab in Orders shows every order with a refund, and each order shows the refund, shipping labels (including return labels and later carrier adjustments that eBay posts to the order) and the profit that's left. It won't handle the case for you, but you'll see exactly what each one cost.

The Short Version

Frequently Asked Questions

How long do I have to respond to an eBay return or item not received request?

3 business days. After that, if it isn't resolved, either you or the buyer can ask eBay to step in.

Does an eBay case count as a defect?

Only if it's closed without seller resolution, meaning eBay steps in and decides you're responsible. Requests you resolve yourself, and cases closed in your favor, don't count.

Do I have to accept a return if my listing says no returns?

For changes of mind, no. For items that are not as described, damaged or the wrong item, yes. The eBay Money Back Guarantee covers those regardless of your return policy.

When do I need signature confirmation on eBay?

On orders with a total of $750 or more, including shipping and tax. Without it, tracking that shows delivery may not be enough to win an item not received case at that price.

Can I appeal an eBay case decision?

Yes, within 30 calendar days of the case closing. You need new information, like tracking, signature proof or photos you didn't provide before.

See What Every Return Really Costs

Autotabit pulls refunds, return labels and fees onto each eBay order so you see your real profit after returns and cases.

Start Free

Tim, founder of Autotabit

eBay seller for over 25 years.

Share this article:

Have a case story, good or bad? Contact me using the link in the footer — I read every message.